The Board of Equalization decides one thing: was your home worth less than the Assessor’s number on January 1 of the assessment year? Recent sales of similar homes are the strongest evidence. In my study of random homes, about 1 in 4 was assessed above recent sales of similar homes. The hard part is picking the right sales.

1. Pick a few, not many

Three to five good comparable sales beat a long list. Every weak comparable gives the Assessor something to argue with, and the Board will notice if you included a house that isn’t really similar.

2. Match the home, then the place

  • Size: living area within about 20% of yours.
  • Age and condition: built within about 15 years, and a similar grade or quality.
  • Lot: a similar lot size, unless you adjust for it.
  • Location: the same neighborhood first. A sale across a freeway or in a different school area is a weaker comparable than one two blocks away, even if it is closer on the map.

3. Pick sales close to January 1

Sales from the year before the valuation date are the baseline, and the closer to January 1 the better. If the market moved, adjust for time, or use sales before January 1, not after. A sale from the following summer shows what the market did later, not what your home was worth on the date that counts.

4. Adjust for differences

No two homes match. Adjust each sale to your home: a larger house sold for more, so deduct for the extra living area; a bigger lot, deduct for it; an older house, add for it. Show your numbers. Keep the total adjustment on each sale small. If you need to adjust more than about 15%, it isn’t a good comparable.

5. Use arm’s-length sales only

Skip foreclosures, sales between relatives, and sales that included other property. They don’t show market value.

6. Add evidence that explains your numbers

Photos of problems the Assessor didn’t account for (see the January 1 photos), a contractor estimate for needed repairs, and any error in the county’s record of your home (wrong square footage, bedrooms or bathrooms).

The free check picks and adjusts comparable sales this way for King, Pierce, Snohomish, Clark, Kitsap and Spokane homes, and the $39 appeal packet puts them into the petition and evidence the Board expects. This is general information, not legal advice.