Property tax appeal in Puyallup, Pierce County

In 2025, 8% of Puyallup homes that sold were assessed above their sale price.

Puyallup has 13,171 residential properties in the Pierce County assessment roll. Recent comparable sales average $608,316. If your assessed value is higher than what similar homes are selling for, you may be overpaying property taxes.

Check your Puyallup property

Enter your address to instantly compare your assessment to recent sales in Puyallup.

Check my assessment

Takes 10 seconds. No signup required.

Assessed value ÷ sale price in Puyallup

392 homes sold in 2025. The typical one was assessed at 91% of its price.

Assessed values are Pierce County‘s as of January 1, 2026; sales are 2025 residential sales. A home that sells is often re-assessed close to its price, so the share assessed above the price is likely higher among homes that didn’t sell.

ZIP codes in Puyallup

ZIPHomes2025 salesAssessed above price
98371 5,967 165 8%
98372 3,927 125 9%
98374 2,483 79 8%
98373 794 23 4%

Puyallup property stats

Total Properties
13,171
Average Home Size
1,900 sq ft
Average Year Built
1976
Average Bedrooms
3.3
Average Bathrooms
2.1
Year Built Range
1872–2026

Recent sales in Puyallup

Comparable Sales on File
1,511
Average Sale Price
$608,316
Average Price per Sq Ft
$347

These numbers are based on arm’s-length residential sales in Pierce County records. Your specific property may differ—run a free check above for personalized comps.

How to appeal property taxes in Puyallup

Property tax appeals in Puyallup follow the same Pierce County process. You can file with the Board of Equalization until July 1, or 60 days after your value notice is mailed, whichever is later. The key to a successful appeal is strong comparable sales evidence—homes similar to yours that sold for less than your assessed value. Our tool finds those comps automatically and generates appeal documents you can file in about 10 minutes.