Understanding this difference helped me turn my frustration into a plan. Assessed value and market value are not the same, and the gap between them is what matters most.

Market value is the price your home would sell for right now. It changes all the time. It’s the number you see on Zillow or Redfin, or what a similar house nearby just sold for.

Assessed value is the county’s estimate of your home’s market value as of January 1 for that year. It’s calculated by a computer model that looks at hundreds of thousands of properties, not by someone visiting your house. When prices are rising, this estimate often falls behind. When the market drops quickly, it can end up much too high.

Assessed value is not the same as your sale price. It’s just a computer’s estimate for your home on a single day. If that estimate is wrong, you can appeal it.

The gap, when your assessment is higher than what your home is actually worth, is what you focus on in an appeal. In my situation, the difference was clear. The county valued my home at about $1.4 million, but the bank’s appraisal when I bought it was around $1,000,000. That’s not a rounding error. That’s a case.

I’m not the only one. I looked at every King County home sold in 2025 and compared the sale price to the county’s value for January 1, 2026. About one in six homes is now assessed above its actual sale price, which was set by a real buyer months before the county’s valuation date.

Histogram of King County homes sold in 2025: assessed value as a share of sale price. Most are assessed below their sale price; 15.5% are assessed above it.
15,879 King County homes sold in 2025 (valid market sales). Assessed value = the county’s January 1, 2026 value. Source: King County Assessor public data.

The January 1 rule: what you need to know before moving forward

The county sets the value for every home as of January 1, and that’s the only date the Board of Equalization considers. This leads to two important points:

  • What matters: sales of similar homes near January 1. If those homes sold for less than your assessment, you have a case.
  • What doesn’t matter is if the market drops later in the year, like in May. You can’t appeal this year’s value based on that. It will be reflected in next year’s assessment, so that’s when you should check again.

How to check the gap yourself

  1. Find your assessed value. It’s on your value notice, or look up your parcel on the King County Assessor’s site.
  2. Find three to five comparable sales. Look for homes with similar size, age, and style, within about half a mile, and sold as close to January 1 as possible.
  3. Compare the numbers. If most of the comparable homes sold for much less than your assessment, you likely have a case for appeal. If they sold for more, you probably don’t, unless the county has your square footage wrong or there are issues with your house that the model missed.

Or skip the spreadsheet. The free check compares your property to over 57,000 recent King County sales and tells you if your assessment is fair.

If there is a real gap, you have the same opportunity I had. Here’s how to appeal it, step by step.